Bernard Chapin has an excellent review of Brian Anderson’s book on South Park Conservatives, in today’s issue of Mens News Daily. Anderson’s book claims that there is a new breed of person on the Right, especially among the young, who espouse conservative values but enjoy earthy popular culture without embarrassment and are tired of leftist claims of moral superiority. (The term appears to have been invented by columnist Andrew Sullivan.) Chapin writes,
“If the existence of the South Parker surprises traditional conservatives, imagine how unnerving it must be for your average liberal to discover that the guy who sat next to him during Phish’s last concert had the Opinion Journal delivered to his Inbox every morning.”
Anderson’s book says that such South Park conservatives have mounted a very effective grass-roots counterrevolutionary campaign against the reigning media, whom he correctly describes as overwhelmingly left of center. He cites the TV show South Park and comedians such as Dennis Miller plus numerous other writers, columnists, and bloggers who are puncturing the sacred cows of modern liberalism.
Chapin identifies a central motivation of South Park Conservatives as a simple wish for freedom to say what they think:
“One of the vilest villains in Anderson’s book is not actually a program or a person, but a phrase: ‘creating a hostile environment.’ This gibberish has been used for all kinds of nefarious purposes by the cultural inquisitors.”
Anderson’s book, as Chapin says, fully documents the illiberalism of today’s liberals, which one should hardly think necessary at this time but does still seem to require continued argumentation, given that the Left still retains control of most of the cuture and academy:
“Anderson’s belief that conservatives have stopped losing the culture war is certainly contestable. Ask any kid in the United States between 10 [yes, I meant 10] and 18 what their favorite kind of music is, and I’ll bet you that at least fifty percent, regardless of race or socioeconomic background, will say ‘rap’ or ‘hip hop.’ Furthermore, all of the blogs, Foxnews, NRO and techcentralstation’s in the world cannot outdo the power of Hollywood’s alternative lifestyle worshipping generofilms.”
I would refer to truly liberal persons on the Right as liberals, but I think that the phenomenon these writers are documenting is a real one by whatever name. Undoubtedly Anderson’s book will be come another right-oriented bestseller, which says something in itself.